On Sunday, the San Gabriels and San Bernardinos were hit with a surprise summer monsoon storm – one that dumped 4 inches of rain in an hour on Mount Baldy. The National Weather Service described it as a “once every 500 years” weather event and many of the mountain communities are still digging out of the mud and storm debris. Modern Hiker reader Rebecca was on Mount Baldy and was caught in the storm just after summiting. This is her story of that afternoon.

 

I have become a bit of an outdoor nerd over the past two years. I love it. Nothing makes me happier than running around mountains. The mountains are where I find peace and everything feels right.

My first big adventure was the “Rim to Rim Grand Canyon” hike in October of 2013 and I was totally over geared – my pack was over thirty pounds for a day hike. I was worried something could go wrong but nothing did. I fell in love with the outdoors and was off to my next adventure. As my hiking progressed, so did my packing – I began shedding more and more gear wherever I could. I do just about everything in trail runners and bring a minimal amount of gear, food, and water – now the heaviest piece of gear is my camera.

image by Rebecca Brinegar

How could you argue with that scenery?

A group of friends and I day-hiked Mt. Whitney in July of 2013. As a native of Los Angeles I really enjoyed the “prep hikes.” They introduced me to the Los Angeles backcountry, a side of LA that I was totally unfamiliar with. These hikes were also good because I got to know my boundaries, learn a lot about how to handle unexpected situations and especially weather. I had no idea how quickly the weather can change in our mountains, especially in the winter – and along with those lessons I also learned that getting stuck in backcountry snow, wind or hail storms is definitely not fun.

But it’s summer now and I am headed back to Mt. Whitney in a few weeks, so I figured to train I would start with a local trail I had yet to complete: Mt. Baldy summit via the Old Baldy Trail.

On Sunday the weather was in the mid 70’s with a little drizzle. I texted my brother to let him know I was heading up Mt. Baldy and that I would check in by 6:00pm at the latest. I stopped to talk to a ranger about weather and figured he could help me decide if I should go for Old Baldy Trail or take the Ski Hut Trail which provides more coverage in case of lighting. He said there was no thunder or lighting yesterday, that the weather felt great, and that I should go for it.

I always hike with friends but nobody was up for this crazy hike so I figured I could do it on my own. I had just returned from two weeks in the Himalaya and had made it to Everest Base Camp in a three day blizzard, dodging rock slides in white-out conditions. It was bitter cold above 17,000 feet… so a 12 mile solo up Old Baldy Trail? No big deal, right?

Photo by Rebecca Brinegar

Old Baldy Trail

Old Baldy is tough. 12.8 miles with 5744’ of gain. What would normally take me three hours took four. I reached the summit at 3:00pm and there were ten others when I topped out.

It started to drizzle. My gut told me to go down the Ski Hut Trail but that meant I would have to hitch a ride back to my car. I met a man named Arun who also came up Old Baldy Trail and we decided to head down together.

Within a half an hour that light drizzle turned to rain and thunder began to roar. Lighting struck the trail ahead of us. We were on a exposed ridge above 9000 feet and with no cover in sight. We ran to the tree line, stashed our bags, and crouched under the first tree we saw.

Within minutes the rain turned to hail. We kept moving from tree to tree to get better coverage. We moved around so much it was not clear where the trail was anymore. We were soaking wet and covered in hail. The thunder and lighting were relentless. I was scared, getting cold and beginning to shiver. Arun kept me calm and helped me stay warm. I was in shorts with a light rain jacket was and he was worried I was going into hypothermia. When he asked me for my last name I knew we were in trouble.

Photo by Arnin Ponnusamy

Hail on the Trail – Photo by Arun Ponnusamy

We decided to make a move. It had been nearly an hour in the monsoon rain. It did not feel like the storm was going to let up and we needed to get lower. Our first priority was to find the trail. We stumbled around on the side of a ridge. The rain was so heavy you could not make sense of anything. Arun had a trail map downloaded on his GPS and saw the trail was above us. We hiked back up to the ridge and were back on course. The storm was letting up. I have never been happier to see a trail.

The next six miles was slow going. Rain on and off. We would lose the trail, backtrack and get back on it – or think we were off course because the trail was so washed out we could not believe it was same thing we hiked up. We had to use our hands and feet to get across many parts. It was dark by the time we crossed Bear Flats. Finally, only two miles to go.

The rain stopped and we heard helicopters in the canyon. Arun had a headlamp, I did not. Mudslides everywhere. Trees and plants were flattened out on all side of us. It took every ounce of energy to navigate the trail in the dark. The trail ended and we were at a swollen creek, which was strange because neither of us remembered crossing a creek. It was pitch dark. I could not believe we were lost again – but after scouting around we found the trailhead sign – this wasn’t a swollen creek, this was Bear Canyon Road.

Within a minute flashlights appeared. It was Search and Rescue. We gave them all the info we had on who we saw at the summit, what they looked like, and the routes we believed they took. Within another 100 feet we ran into LAFD removing a body from a car that was swept up in the flash flood.

We got back to Baldy Village to find a ton of search and rescue vehicles, fire department, ambulances, crevasse rescue and news vans. Baldy Lodge never felt so good. We ordered a beer, thawed out by the fire and spoke with several locals displaced by the storm. It was bittersweet. I was very confused by what just happened, sad for the losses, but happy to call my brother and tell him I was safe.

The takeaway… Sunday was a “perfect storm” of bad decision making. I got cocky.

Photo by Gilberto Gil

Flooded car and SAR tag in the aftermath – Photo by Gilberto Gil

I’ve been taught a few lessons in previous winters but completely underestimated summer. It is one thing to “go lite” but it is another thing to “go stupid.” I went to 10,000’ with potential for rain in shorts, a tank top, light second layer and a rain jacket. I had a spare lightweight jacket and longer pants in my pack that were drenched by the time I wanted to put them on. In other words, pack cover and dry bag – both which I own – should have been in my pack. I also forgot my headlamp and left my emergency kit at home because I never use it. 10 essentials are key and I will never hike without them again.

I was also reminded just how dumb it is to hike alone. I intended to find someone to head down with but that is only because the weather started looking nasty. What if there was nobody at summit or if I would have summited earlier in the day when the weather looked better? I may have headed down solo and got caught in the flash flood. It could have been worse.

Furthermore, a firefighter on the scene was shocked I started so late. Most thunder and lightning storms hit in the afternoon. I knew that but began at 11:00am. I’m getting lazy.

Last but not least, I texted my brother to let him know I was heading up Blady but did not tell him which trail I intended to hike. It’s important to be detailed. If an emergency happens, first responders do not need to waste time or resources.

Bottom line; I was not clear on the effects a summer monsoon can have on hiking and if I want to play in the backcountry I need to get educated. I was not 100% clear on how to navigate the thunder and lighting. What if we did not have the GPS app or Arun’s phone went dead? I want to be solid on the moves I should make under rain, thunder, lighting, bears mountain lions, rattlesnakes, ankle rolls and everything in between. The Wilderness Travel Course is in my near future.

With all that said – trust your gut. My gut told me go down the Ski Hut Trail which would have given me more coverage but my ego wanted me to finish Old Baldy Trail. In reality I knew it was not the best day to climb Baldy in the first place. I will not make any of these mistakes again.

All photos by Rebecca Brinegar unless otherwise noted. 

21 Comments

bob Sep 5, 2014 11:09

The reason Brandon is so harsh is because this story is all too common and tragically sometimes ends in death. I know dozens of people like Rebecca who while fit just don't realize or disregard the dangers that exist in the wilderness. The real tragedy is that these deaths are almost always preventable. Rebecca was lucky. Others may not be so lucky. I read about incidents like this every year and it is always the same story. Fit person hiking alone with minimal gear slips and dies from a fall or gets lost and dies of hypothermia or doesn't bring extra water and dies from dehydration when the temperature soars above the forecast. etc. THEY CALL IT THE WILDERNESS FOR A REASON. It is deceiving when it is so close to a major metro area and there are dozens of people on the same trail. The dangers are the same.

Leave a Reply to bob Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rebecca Sep 3, 2014 11:09In reply to: Margo

Thanks for your service Margo. It sounds like you/your team would be a good person to address the ranger that gave me the go ahead that day. The weather report I looked up said no t-storms and the ranger confirmed it. That is your last line of defense. I never would have gone up if the ranger did not give me a thumbs up. I always check with the ranger... he literally said "Go for it... I would." That + weather report... was a "Perfect Storm." I have some solid hiking experience, very familiar with ten essentials... I hike Baldy frequently... reality is too much experience often results in getting lazy... that is the key issue here and a mistake I personally will not make again.

Leave a Reply to Rebecca Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Margo Sep 3, 2014 09:09

Becca I'm glad you made it off the mountain safely. I want to add one more critical point you spoke about but did not expand on. When people go out without proper gear and knowledge, the SAR workers that have to go find them are also at risk. I was on the mountain that night, searching for hikers, I shattered my ankle trying to reach two stranded hikers off the backside of Harwood. They were dressed similar to you and in trouble. I am a volunteer and avid outdoors woman and I know an accept the risk of what I do. What I ask of all is to pause and think about what you are about to do, educate yourself on proper gear and wilderness skills, make sure people know where your going and always always listen to that little voice in your head. If you do those things then I'll know my sacrafive had value and may prevent a next time.
I am a member of West Valley SAR, Mount Baldy is in our response area, if you would like to learn more about the ten essentials and safe travel tips please visit our website. We are a non-profit totally volunteer team attached to the San Bernardino County Sherift office. My team members are an exceptional group of highly trained first responders and I'm both honored and grateful for their service.

Leave a Reply to Margo Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Marco Aug 7, 2014 14:08

Well, she made a ton of mistakes but survived, wetter but wiser.

Leave a Reply to Marco Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

elcrock Aug 7, 2014 12:08In reply to:

Turning around less than 30 yards from the top of San G was one of the best (and hardest) decisions I've made in my relatively brief hiking time. It also made the next days turn around at Wellman's divide at San J very easy----since this attempt at the challenge was already toast. Sheesh---What a weekend!

Leave a Reply to elcrock Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

elcrock Aug 7, 2014 12:08In reply to: Brandon

" Bottom line… always prepare for the worst case scenario (even if it means carrying a heavier pack all day), bring the essentials, check the weather forecast for the day of, and day after your excursion, and don’t be afraid to cancel an event due to bad weather"

I believe that's what she said she took away from that experience. No reason to be so harsh w/ your judgement. Also she checked w/ a ranger before going up and he gave her the all clear go ahead. Let's all attempt to have some mutual respect and try to help each other become better hikers instead of self righteously claiming the moral high ground and berating one another. Everyone on here I imagine has made a poor call that they regretted at some point in their outdoor adventures. Let's have a forum where everyone feels free to share and enlighten each other without the possibility of public shaming.

Leave a Reply to elcrock Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Casey Schreiner Aug 7, 2014 11:08In reply to: Brandon

Brandon,

I think it's safe to say that every single one of us has at one point neglected the Ten Essentials, stayed out too long, taken an unnecessary risk, or otherwise done something stupid on the trail. I, myself have made some pretty dumb moves in my hiking life - but I firmly believe that every mistake you come back alive from is a valuable teaching moment. That's why I have written about both my bad mistakes (including going off-trail with a group at sunset without a light or map or ANYTHING, really) as well as a later, wiser trip when I hiked through unsafe trail conditions but ultimately fought back my summit fever and turned back when it got too dicey.

When I learned that a Modern Hiker reader had been caught in a "once in 500 years" storm, I reached out to Rebecca to see if she would be interested in sharing her story - and she and I agreed that people could learn from her mistakes, too. She acknowledges both in the piece and in our pre-writing communication that she made a lot of errors on this trip but I think you'll agree that her progression of getting the hiking bug, doing big trips, then getting complacent and neglecting basic safety is a fairly common one in the hiking world.

Too often, all we get from stories like this when someone doesn't come back is a story in the LA Times followed by reams of armchair outdoorsmen and hikers who have presumably never made a mistake in their lives piling on insult and incredulity and nothing productive ever comes from it. Here, we have a story of someone who got in over her head, learned valuable lessons, and is now planning on gaining more skills from a resource hikers and backpackers consider invaluable. I don't know about you, but I still think that's a story worth sharing.

Leave a Reply to Casey Schreiner Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

MP Aug 7, 2014 07:08In reply to: Brandon

I totally agree! Your gut should have told you to not go up in the first place. You are lucky that other not-so-smart guy was up there. I also can't believe a ranger gave you the go ahead. That just seems unbelievable. Everyone should have been discouraged to go up that weekend. It sucks to cancel plans (I had to cancel my camping trip that weekend) but it's safer for everyone involved, including the search and rescue team.

Leave a Reply to MP Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Brandon Aug 7, 2014 07:08

I've been a fan of Modern Hiker for a ling while, and this is the first article on the site to EVER make me say WTF!?!? Why is this person a contributor to the site, when it seems like she's into hiking for the hipster niche aspect, and blog-ability of it all (i.e., Rebecca's reply in the comments section stating, "I am actually working on a website that lets you view and review tea houses in the Khumbu").

Rebecca says...

"I have become a bit of an outdoor nerd over the past two years..."

"My first big adventure was the “Rim to Rim Grand Canyon” hike in October of 2013..."

"I had just returned from two weeks in the Himalaya and had made it to Everest Base Camp in a three day blizzard, dodging rock slides in white-out conditions. It was bitter cold above 17,000 feet… so a 12 mile solo up Old Baldy Trail? No big deal, right?"

"As my hiking progressed, so did my packing – I began shedding more and more gear wherever I could.I began shedding more and more gear wherever I could. I do just about everything in trail runners and bring a minimal amount of gear, food, and water"

So Rebecca -
In the last 2 years or less in which you claim to have become serious about hiking, or at least becoming a "hiking nerd," you also thought you had progressed to an expert level? Hiking Baldy solo in $#!tty conditions with a storm forecast, is such a rookie move, which could have cost you everything (see Modern Hiker article from 2009 https://modernhiker.com/2010/12/09/body-found-on-mount-baldy-believed-to-be-michelle-yu/ ). Don't get me wrong, I'm glad you made it out of the situation OK, but people die all the time pulling stunts like this, in way less sketchy spots (the Eaton Canyon Waterfall for example) and wind up putting other peoples lives at risk when they have to be rescued.

Bottom line... always prepare for the worst case scenario (even if it means carrying a heavier pack all day), bring the essentials, check the weather forecast for the day of, and day after your excursion, and don't be afraid to cancel an event due to bad weather.

Leave a Reply to Brandon Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Ranxerox Aug 6, 2014 19:08

What were you thinking? Thunderstorms were forecasted days in advance for the area. Just an incredibly foolish decision. You're very lucky.

Leave a Reply to Ranxerox Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Leave a comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *